|
|
|
Another reason to shelter children from the media...
Published Monday, May 04, 2009 in
share this post

Last week’s news included a story out of Hamilton, OH, about a third grade boy who was expelled from his private Lutheran school after a “hit list” of teachers and fellow students was found in his desk. School officials believe no one was ever actually in danger, and they mention that the boy is known to be “troubled” and previously has been in counseling. The principal says they cannot be too careful in this day and age, while stressing that the school community is praying for the boy.
I believe the school did the right thing by expelling the boy, because sadly the principal is right – we really don’t have any way to know if a child will act on his violent thoughts and feelings. We’ve seen cases of children as young as seven intentionally acting violently to solve problems – remember the little boy in Arizona who killed his father and the father’s friend? It can happen, and a school can’t assume that a child’s “hit list” is merely an expression of anger or frustration. Hopefully, this episode will get this child the help he apparently needs.
We have to ask, though, why a little third grade boy would compile a list of people he fantasizes about hurting or even killing. What sorts of images are in his mind? Why does he think violence would solve his problems? And where did those messages and images originate?
If you’ve read my columns or blogs even a few times, you know what I’m about to say: I’m betting this boy is exposed to huge quantities of media that are inappropriate for a child his age. Now mind you, I don’t know. The news story I read says very little, and it’s possible I’m making an unfair assumption about the level of supervision this boy gets with respect to media.
But given the statistics on children and media, it’s a good guess. According to experts, children are exposed to some six hours of media each day – that’s TV, radio, Internet, personal media players and advertising. For most kids, that’s pretty much all of the hours between the time they get out of school and the time they go to bed.
Moreover, studies confirm that kids are watching shows on TV, playing video games and visiting Internet sites that contain way too much violence, sex, profanity, and disturbing images.
If we wonder why some kids seem to have a bizarre desire to act violently, or why others have a precocious and disturbing interest in sex, or why some use foul and vulgar language, we should look no further than the steady diet of inappropriate material they’re consuming through the media right in their own homes.
Sadly, I’m one who thinks this news story is what happens when we don’t shelter children from images and ideas that are not healthy or wholesome.
| Comments |
By
cate tuten @
Tuesday, May 12, 2009 3:49 AM
|
|
Marybeth,thank you! Thank you! Oh, I say it again, thank you!! Unfortunately, your voice is a soft whisper in a society loosing its hearing. It is no longer cool nor politically correct to hear from God, and I don't mean the god who has been brought down to our level, made into our own personal image of what a "politically correct" god should be. I mean the One and Only true God of Abraham, Issac, and Jacob. Yet, with the One True God ahead of you and behind you, your whisper will reach ears longing to hear. And it Will make a difference for Him. I combine my voice with yours, and with others who stand up and speak the truth. For it is only God's truth that can truly grow our children into mature, responsible, wise, and loving human beings. It is only God's truth that can truly set us free. Thank you for being a light on the hill. For speaking out. I, and many others, hear you. And again, I say thank you...
|
|
|
By
Children's Bedroom Furniture @
Tuesday, May 19, 2009 3:17 PM
|
Mary Beth, I have to agree. Our kids are so overstimulated and have way too much access to unlimited sources of information at their finger tips in this day and age.
It is up to us as parents to establish a filter for them (at least at home). Sadly we don't have much control over the influence they receive while at school with the other kids.
Hopefully the moral foundation we do have control of that is established at home will take precedence over everything else in their life.
Thanks for the awareness!
|
|
|
By
Christopher Wragg @
Thursday, November 12, 2009 3:18 AM
|
"Sadly, I’m one who thinks this news story is what happens when we don’t shelter children from images and ideas that are not healthy or wholesome."
Indeed it is sad you believe that. This is a post paved entirely on a) an unfounded supposition that the child has access to violent media, b) ignores the fact the child was known to be troubled prior to the incident and c) makes use of some fairly suspect (and un-cited) studies and d) makes a whole bunch of hidden assumptions.
For instance, you mention that children consume a lot more digital media these days. Fair enough, this in and of itself says nothing for your supposition, secondly you mention that "studies" mention that children watch far more disturbing content. This in no way links such content to a child's "bizarre desire to act violently", or " a precocious and disturbing interest in sex", or thier use of "foul and vulgar language".
You also assume that violent media = violent child (a quite unproven concept), you assume that children were not violent or troubled prior to the advent of digital media. You again assume that the childs intent was harmful. Before video games were a mainstay children used to do silly things like write "hit lists" or "black lists" for teachers they disliked, for students they disliked even. Ask any Psychologist and they can quite happily inform you that this is a coping mechanism. It's a way of directing anger in a non-harmful way and resolving the child's feelings, "getting thoughts out on paper" as it were.
Ultimately people like yourself who point their fingers at digital media are simply using it as a scapegoat, and are in fact the cause of the problem. Children get ignored because people are too busy blaming the easy targets, rather than actually considering the real problems they face.
|
|
|
Click here to post a comment
|
|